Eye Camera
How Accurate is the Hawk-Eye System for Tennis Line Calls
We know and have seen how video analysis can be used to analyze a tennis players performance, but it can also be used in real time or almost real time to track the ball and even make close line calls. Of course I am talking about the “Shot Spot” or Hawk-Eye system.
If you have watched any Major Tennis since 2006, you will know exactly what Hawk-Eye is. The Hawk-Eye is used to make decisions on line calls that are challenged by the tennis player. Each player (or team if playing doubles) can challenge a line call on any point. They get a maximum of 2 incorrect challenges each set. If the set goes to a tie break an extra challenge is allowed. Basically the Hawk-Eye challenge enables the tennis players to use technology to challenge line calls they think are incorrect.
The technology being used by the Hawk-Eye system is Video Analysis. Here is how it works.
- Multiple cameras are placed around the court and players. These cameras are usually placed high up, so that there is less chance that a player will be blocking the ball from the camera view.
- Multiple cameras are used to ensure accuracy of tracking the ball and to account for possible occlusion (the ball being hidden from the camera view by the players body…)
- The system uses at least 4 high speed video cameras, with a capture rate presumed to be 500 frames per second.
- The camera position is calibrated to determine its position in space and relative to the other cameras in the system. The lines on the court are also used in calibration and to compensate for any camera movement.
- The center of the ball is tracked in 2D by each camera. The ball therefore is like a reflective marker or point on the body. Using the information from all the cameras, the Hawk-Eye system then triangulates the 3D position of the ball.
- This process is done for each captured frame so that a trajectory of the ball can be created and then overlayed on an animated background containing the lines of the tennis court.
- Finally the skid and compression of the ball is measured by examining the position and trajectory of the ball prior to the bounce and its position and trajectory after the bounce. In this way they can determine how long the ball was on the ground and how it skidded over the ground.
- The Hawk-Eye system is said to have an accuracy of 3.6 mm.
I believe that the use of video technology in this way is great for the sport of tennis and for the players piece of mind as well as spectator enjoyment. However we have seen a number of controversial calls with the Hawk-Eye system. Take a look at video of 2 big ones here.
In this first video we see a very tight call for Mikhail Youzhny over Rafael Nadal at Dubai in 2007.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ak8GRRFBN54&feature=player_embedded
This second video is from the Wimbledon final in 2007. Rafael Nadal benefiting from a very close one over Roger Federer.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qKhPQqul7_Y&feature=player_embedded
In both cases we would have to say that the ball likely looked out to the lines judge who made the call. In both cases the player is most likely only challenging the call because it is a crucial point (Yozhny vs Nadal – Set Point, Nadal vs Federer – Break point). The Hawk-Eye system suggests that in both cases these calls were measured as being 1mm IN, meaning the ball was 1mm from being out. Could Hawk-Eye have been wrong in either or both of these calls and what does it mean that it is 2-3 mm accurate but can suggest that the ball was in by only 1mm? Here are some points that may effect the accuracy of the system.
- The camera capture rate of 500 frames per second may be too slow for the hard hitting tennis game of today. Andy Roddick has recorded a fastest serve at 155 mph and ground strokes are often hit with a similar speed. Assuming a capture speed of 500 frames per second or 1 frame every 0.002 seconds, the ball will have moved about 139 mm for every video frame. This may not be sufficient data to determine the position of the ball to within 1 mm.
- The more cameras that are used the better the chance of tracking the ball and the higher the accuracy. However there are possibilities of occlusion by players, tennis rackets and the net, which will lead to reduced accuracy.
- High speed video capture also needs excellent lighting. We have discussed the importance of lighting for high speed capture in a previous post . Therefore the system will work best under a roof with artificial bright lighting and will possibly have a problem tracking the ball outdoors, particularly when there is cloud cover or as it gets later into the evening.
- Assuming everything is perfect for capture, the center of the ball has to be identified as accurately as possible too. If a camera sees the ball at a funny angle or partly occluded the center may not be correctly defined by this one camera and the position of the ball will be inaccurate.
- The skid and compression of the ball is being estimated and extrapolated based on the trajectory of the ball before and after the bounce. Any inaccuracies in tracking the position and flight of the ball will become larger during an extrapolation (estimation of the movement).
The Hawk-Eye system may not be perfect but it is definitely a step up from the eyeball view of a line judge, particularly when the ball is moving at high speed. We believe Hawk-Eye has improved the line calls in Tennis and this is great for the players and spectators alike. However it still leaves room to debate exciting points and close matches. Enjoy the US Open Tennis and hopefully we will not see any controversial Hawk-Eye calls.
About the Author
Dudley Tabakin is Co-Founder of Sadaka, LLC http://videosportsanalysis.blogspot.com, a motion capture and biomechanics consultancy. Clients include FootJoy, Titleist, Warrior Hockey, Vicon Motion Systems, Innovision Systems Inc. and other Sports and Motion capture and biomechanics software companies
|
|
Lens Wide Angle Fish Eye For Digital Camera Cell Phone $1.29 |
|
|
Fisheye Fish eye 0.18x Camera Lens for CANON EOS 450D 300D 50D 40D 30D 20D 10D $57.94 |
|
|
185° Detachable Fish Eye Fisheye Lens for iPhone 4S 4G 4 iTouch Camera DC112 $15.99 |
|
|
Official Sony Playstation 3 PS3 Eye Camera Eyetoy for Move NEW $18.99 |
|
|
3in1 Fish Eye Lens + Wide Angle +Micro Lens Camera Kit for iPhone 4 4S iPad HTC $11.95 |
|
|
Mini Door Eye Hole Security Color CCTV 1/4″ CMOS Camera @US $17.00 |
|
|
Camera Eye Cup/Eyecup/Augenmuschel for Nikon DK-21 D70 $2.99 |
|
|
EXCEL TEC EYE LINE SENSOR CAMERA TI5150FS5-C $188.00 |
|
|
Camera Eye Cup/Eyecup——Canon Ef EOS 300D/350D/400D/450D $3.99 |
|
|
Camera Eye Cup/Eyecup for Canon Ef EOS 500D/550D/1000D $3.99 |
|
|
37mm 0.21X fisheye lens Fish Eye Canon Nikon Sony JVC Panasonic camera camcorder $33.90 |
|
|
New TV Clip for PS3 Move Eye Camera Mount Holder Stand $3.29 |
|
|
for Nokia N95 8GB N97 / Palm PRE Camera * Fish Eye Lens $15.99 |
|
|
Marvels: Eye of the Camera NEW by Kurt Busiek $22.39 |
|
|
Brand New Dog Cat Pet’s Eye View Digital Clip-On Collar Camera Cam Pet Supply $8.83 |
|
|
TOP Quality IN CAR HD DVR VIDEO CAMERA RECORD 2.5″ LCD 720P ROAD EYE HOT SELLER $71.99 |
|
|
Canon EOS 3 35mm SLR Film camera only body Eye Control *EXC++* $300.99 |
|
|
37mm 0.21X fisheye lens Fish Eye Canon Nikon Sony Panasonic JVC camera camcorder $32.99 |
|
|
KE Keen Eye Gyroscope Camera 27″ Big RC Helicopter – NEW $129.95 |
|
|
PlayStation PS2 Eye Toy Groove WITH Camera – NEW IN BOX $24.99 |
|
|
Eye-Fi Mobile 8GB Wi-Fi Wireless Memory Card SDHC For DSLR Cameras $118.78 |
|
|
Mame Eye Lenz Reflex Camera Compact Mini SLR Camera SUSMDICA SANKO JAPAN NEW $149.99 |
|
|
180 Degree Fish eye Wide Angle Lens Phone Camera 1127 $7.99 |
|
|
PS3 Move bundle: Motion & Navigation controller-Eye Camera & Sharp Shoorter Gun! $67.00 |
|
|
Vintage Bell & Howell Electric Eye 8mm Movie Camera Very Good Works $28.00 |
|
|
NEW EYE TOY PLAY 2 GAME WITH CAMERA FOR PS2 PLAYSTATION 2 SYSTEM CONSOLE EYETOY $24.95 |
|
|
Vintage Bell & Howell Electric Eye 8mm Movie Camera $0.99 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye E7B for Canon Camera 580EX / 580EX II $2.37 |
|
|
NEW Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye for CANON Camera 430EX 430EX II E6B $2.37 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Cover Eliminates Red eye E4B for Nikon Camera SB-600 SB600 $2.37 |
|
|
NEW Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye for CANON Camera 430EX 430EX II E6B $1.92 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye E7B for Canon Camera 580EX / 580EX II $1.92 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Cover Eliminates Red eye E4B for Nikon Camera SB-600 SB600 $1.92 |
|
|
NEW Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye for CANON Camera 430EX 430EX II E6B $2.49 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye E7B for Canon Camera 580EX / 580EX II $2.49 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Cover Eliminates Red eye E4B for Nikon Camera SB-600 SB600 $2.49 |
|
|
TV Clip Mount Holder Stand For PS3 Move Eye Camera New $3.19 |
|
|
New TV Clip for PS3 Move Eye Camera Mount Holder Stand $3.20 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye E7B for Canon Camera 580EX / 580EX II $2.39 |
|
|
NEW Flash Bounce Diffuser Eliminates Red eye for CANON Camera 430EX 430EX II E6B $2.39 |
|
|
Flash Bounce Diffuser Cover Eliminates Red eye E4B for Nikon Camera SB-600 SB600 $2.39 |
|
|
Protable 180° Fish Eye Camera Lens With Back Case Cover For iPhone 4S 4G DC127 $12.39 |
|
|
Eye Toy: Play (incl. EyeToy Camera) $32.07 |
|
|
No.2 Hawk Eye Camera. Kodak $10.00 |
|
|
Full HD 1080P Eagle Eye Helmet LCD Go Outdoor Camera Sport Action Cam DVR $160.50 |
|
|
Disney Cars TIM RIMMER Camera Fixed Eyes Mattel Diecast Loose New $5.99 |
|
|
NEW PETS EYE VIEW CAMERA UNCLE MILTON $9.99 |
|
|
New PlayStation Eye Camera Adjustable Mounting Clip By CTA Digital Color- Black $4.99 |
|
|
Movie Camera,Vintage,Emdeko,8mm Reflex Zoom,Automatic Electric eye,with case $39.50 |
|
|
180 Degree Fish Eye Wide Angle Lens for Cell Phone Notebook laptop Camera $8.39 |
|
|
New ATN L-3 Thermal-Eye X50 Thermal Imaging Camera $3,695.00 |
|
|
Hasselblad Tutorial ~ The Eye/Camera/Image ~ 1973 $10.00 |
|
|
Thermal-Eye 250D Thermal Imager Infrared Camera FLIR $3,500.00 |
|
|
sony playstation 3 eye toy camera ps3 move controller $14.00 |
|
|
SONY EYE TOY USB CAMERA COMPATIBLE W/PS2/PS2 SLIM/PS3/PC + FREE SHIPPING!!! $22.95 |
|
|
700TVL Security Camera Outdoor Eye CCTV Dome Heavy Duty 2.8-12mm Adjustable $88.00 |
|
|
Jelly Lens Fish Eye Wide Angle for Phone Digital Camera $2.29 |
|
|
Kodak Brownie Bulls-Eye Film Camera–Near Mint $45.00 |
|
|
Raytheon Thermal-Eye 300D FLIR Infrared Thermal Imager Camera $1,995.00 |
|
|
Jelly Lens Fish Eye Wide Angle for Cell Phone Camera $2.29 |
|
|
Skinit Tiger Eyes Skin for BlackBerry Tour 9630 with camera $14.99 |
|
|
Vtg. Polaroid Electric Eye Model 900 Camera Original Owner’s Instruction Manual $14.95 |
|
|
Vintage Polaroid Model J66 Electric Eye Land Camera W Timer $19.95 |
|
|
Vintage Bell & Howell Electric Eye 8mm Turret Movie Camera Very Good Working $54.99 |
|
|
MARVELS EYE OF THE CAMERA # 1 2 3 4 SPIDER-MAN AVENGERS $5.95 |
|
|
Vintage POLAROID 900 Electric Eye LAND CAMERA + Extras $69.95 |
|
|
Marvels: Eye of The Camera HC Kurt Busiek Roger Stern!! $18.00 |
|
|
TV Clip Stand Holder mount for PS3 move Eye Camera UK $3.63 |
|
|
Canon EOS Elan II E With Eye Control Film SLR Camera Body Free US Shipping $19.99 |
|
|
Eastman Kodak Vintage Camera, No. 2A Folding Cartridge Hawk-Eye Model B $14.97 |
|
|
Official Sony Playstation 3 Eye Camera Mounting strip NEW $7.99 |
|
|
Sony PS3 Official Eye USB Camera SCPH-98047 New (Playstation 3 Cam) 711719804703 $34.95 |
|
|
Star D Gold Line Eye Cup Flexible Rubber Soft, Comfortable Improves Camera Focus $9.50 |
|
|
Antique/Vintage Eastman Kodak No. 2 Hawk Eye Camera (30′s/40′s?) $34.95 |
|
|
4-9mm Camera Lens*4*DVC-20 DVC20 Dlink DoorPhone i2eye $49.99 |
|
|
Acer Aspire 5920 Crystal Eye Camera $14.99 |
|
|
EYE CUP for NIKON D3100 D5000 SLR Digital Camera $9.99 |
|
|
rubber Eye cup for Nikon F3 cameras D1 D1H F5 F4 eyecu $4.99 |
|
|
Rubber Eye cup for Nikon cameras F2 FE2 FM2 FM New $8.99 |
|
|
2Eye Cup Eyecup for Nikon F F2 F2A F3 FM2 FE2 FA Camera $12.99 |
|
|
YASHIRA CAMERA DENTAL EYE FILM BASED WITH LENS $59.00 |
|
|
2 Minolta Camera Eye Cups Eyecup X-700 X-370 NEW in Box $7.99 |
|
|
Polaroid ‘Electric Eye’ Camera, Model J66. Orginal Case,Book,Flash Bulbs,Coate $7.99 |
|
|
Revere Eye-Matic 127 Camera $25.00 |
|
|
vintage 3 lens Keystone Electric Eye 8mm film camera Bausch & Lomb lenses WORKS $7.00 |
|
|
Eye Toy Groove For PS2 (NO CAMERA) Game $0.99 |
|
|
New Playstation 3 Motion Sensors Move Bundle PS3 Camera Eye,Controller & 2 Games $89.99 |
|
|
MAMIYA EYE CORRECTION LENS ADAPTER SEKOR CAMERA NEW $35.99 |
|
|
DOGTEK Eyenimal Pet Video Camera – 4 GO HD Video Pet Cam for dogs and cats $65.00 |
|
|
Vintage, collectible, Kodak Folding Hawk-Eye Camera $15.00 |
|
|
Yashica Dental Eye 35mm Film Camera w/ 55mm 1.4 lens $12.27 |
|
|
Kodak No. 2 Film Pack Hawk-Eye Camera W/Box & Book NR $5.00 |
|
|
CCTV Camera Surveillance Security Secret Eye $25.53 |
|
|
Ruber Eyecup Eye Cup Eb for Canon Digital Camera EOS 5D Mark II/5D/50D/40D—GOOD $2.49 |
|
|
Eye Cup Eyepiece Ef fr Canon Camera EOS 300D/350D/400D/450D/500D/550D/1000D—BEST $2.49 |
|
|
Eyecup Eye Cup Protector DK-21 for Nikon Camera D700/D300S/D300/D200/D90/D80/D70 $2.49 |
|
|
EARLY NIKON F CAMERA W/EYE LEVEL PRISM AND RARE 58mm F/1,4 LENS $300.00 |
|
|
Sony PS3 Move Eye Camera 10′ Extension Cable PDP New (Playstation 3 10 ft) $13.50 |
|
|
MARVELS EYE OF THE CAMERA 2 Marvel Comics B & W VARIANT $2.99 |
|
|
VINTAGE BELL & HOWELL 240 MOVIE CAMERA 16 MM 16MM w CASE MANUAL ELECTRIC EYE $89.99 |
